The Dream Hotel
by Laila Lalami
336pp (Hardcover)
My Rating: 6/10
LibraryThing Rating: 3.8/5
Goodreads Rating: 3.61/5
 

As a Bookshop affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

The Dream Hotel by Laila Lalami is a standalone literary science fiction novel set in a version of the not-too-distant future where the Risk Assessment Administration monitors data to evaluate the likelihood that an individual will commit a crime. It’s a chillingly plausible story that will likely make you wish to go off the grid completely, and I thought it was excellent at creating a future that seems possible based on our history and present. However, my initial high opinion of it faded somewhat by the time I reached the end. Some parts of it were too drawn out, and it didn’t delve quite as deeply into exploring its ideas as I’d anticipated, especially given its earlier setup and a new perspective introduced later in the story that I thought would have greater significance.

In this version of the future, the Risk Assessment Administration was created after someone shot a bunch of people on live television during a Super Bowl half-time show, killing more than 100 attendees total. After the fact, it was clear that there was a lot of data indicating that this man would do something like this—including documentation of abusive behavior, recent ammo purchases on his credit card, and internet searches related to bypassing security—and these deaths could have been prevented if all these factors had been taken into consideration earlier. In response, a system that measured each person’s potential to commit a crime was developed: one that tracked each individual’s data and updated their risk assessment score accordingly. Though some wondered if this was too intrusive, studies showed that suicide rates and gun deaths decreased dramatically after this system’s implementation, and many people found the score to be a number that they barely had to think about since it did not have a huge impact on their lives and only came up when applying for a mortgage or such.

This had been the case for Sara, the main character, until the day she was stopped at the airport on her way back from an annual work-related conference. When she finally learned she was being held because her risk assessment score had risen slightly above what was considered “safe,” she had difficulty thinking of anything she could have done to raise her score to that level. But it turned out she didn’t technically do anything to raise her numbers: the implant she started using as a sleep aid after the birth of her twins had been recording her dreams, and her risk assessment score increased because she had dreamed of harming her husband.

Like most of the women held in the same facility because of their potential to commit a crime, Sara has been kept there for far longer than the 3 weeks she was told to expect, and she’s been in detention for about 10 months at the beginning of the novel. She’s been told repeatedly that there will be no hindrances to her release as long as she keeps her head down and follows the rules, but she has not even been able to schedule her first hearing and has been growing increasingly frustrated as her sentence continues to drag on with no end in sight. This is the story of the obstacles she faces while in detainment, her attempts to make sense of the dreams that landed her there, and her struggle to regain her freedom and reunite with her family.

As you may have inferred from my opening paragraph, I found The Dream Hotel to be a bit frustrating. It hooked me immediately with its vision of a near future that seemed all too close and eerily plausible, and earlier parts of the novel had some quotes that stood out and made me pause, such as:

“To be a woman was to watch yourself not just through your own eyes, but through the eyes of others.” (page 43)

During the first third or so, I was especially interested in seeing how it engaged with the variety of topics it touched on and seemed likely to explore: for example, those related to data tracking, technology, and freedom; the intersection between race/immigration and imprisonment (given that Sara details her experiences with flights as the daughter of Moroccan immigrants and is likely detained in part due to that); and how capitalism ties into the exploitation of detainees for profit.

Unfortunately, the novel did not delve into these subjects much more as it progressed, and I found my interest waning during the second half. It wasn’t a bad book, but it was one that had potential to be so much better than it was, and I was disappointed that it kept teasing compelling or thoughtful aspects only to hold back on further engagement with them. It outright annoyed me that there was one section in the middle following another perspective that seemed like it was going to be far more significant than it ended up being, especially given that it really felt like it was leading into a major subplot that never came to be.

This may have worked better for me if it delved further into the characters, or at least the main protagonist. Sara is a deeply sympathetic character with her terrible circumstances and grief at missing so many of her babies’ earliest milestones, and her overall emotional journey and realizations about handling her situation are rewarding. She’s not a poorly developed character by any means, but she wasn’t particularly dimensional, especially considering she’s the only character with a decent amount of development. She certainly didn’t have the amount of depth or sort of vivid narrative voice (told in third person) that made her everyday life at the detainment center—which included working, conversing, trying to set up hearings, visiting with her family on occasion, dreaming, and writing in her dream journal—remain compelling throughout later parts of the novel. (Maybe I just have exceptionally strange dreams, but I also felt like most of the sections detailing her dreams as they were happening did not feel truly dreamlike.) There’s one instance of a climate-change-induced wildfire that breaks up some of the mundanity while illustrating the horrible treatment of these people who are prisoners in all but name, but this section was only slightly more interesting than the novel had become at that point. The novel started to feel like it had overstayed its welcome a bit past the halfway point.

The Dream Hotel does have a satisfying, meaningful ending, though it’s not as strong as it would have been if the added section shown from a different perspective hadn’t made it seem like it had been leading up to a more momentous conclusion. Given that there was a dangling bigger event that was then mostly dropped, it seemed like more would happen or be addressed in its final pages.

Though I’d hoped The Dream Hotel would offer more to question and ponder, I did appreciate how it highlighted the inhumane treatment of imprisoned/detained people and the need for community and bonds with each other, as well as the deep empathy that runs through it. Between these strengths and its promising first few chapters, it had a lot of potential to become one of my frequently recommended books, but ultimately, it felt underbaked.

My Rating: 6/10

Where I got my reading copy: I purchased it.

Read or Listen to an Excerpt from The Dream Hotel

I’m thrilled to have a guest post by Deva Fagan to share with you today! Her novel House of Dusk, which is described as “a romantic epic fantasy featuring a fire-wielding nun grappling with her dark past and a young spy caught between her mission and a growing attraction to an enemy princess,” was just released in hardcover and ebook last week. I’m excited she’s here to discuss some books and resources she used as inspirations in “Real History for Fantasy Worlds.”

Cover of House of Dusk by Deva Fagan
More Information

 

About HOUSE OF DUSK:

A romantic epic fantasy featuring a fire-wielding nun grappling with her dark past and a young spy caught between her mission and a growing attraction to an enemy princess

With complex relationships, a rich and mythic world, and brisk pacing, this standalone novel is perfect for fans of Tasha Suri, Samantha Shannon, and Shannon Chakraborty

Ten years ago, Sephre left behind her life as a war hero and took holy vows to seek redemption for her crimes, wielding the flames of the Phoenix to purify the dead. But as corpses rise, a long-dead god stirs, and shadowy serpents creep from the underworld, she has no choice but to draw on the very past she’s been trying so hard to forget.

Orphaned by the same war Sephre helped win, Yeneris has trained half her life to be the perfect spy, a blade slipped deep into the palace of her enemies. Undercover as bodyguard to Sinoe, a princess whose tears unleash prophecy, Yeneris is searching for the stolen bones of a saint. Her growing attraction to the princess, however, is proving dangerous, and Yeneris struggles to balance her feelings for Sinoe with her duty to her people.

As gods are reborn and spirits destroyed, the world trembles on the edge of a second cataclysm. Sephre must decide whether to be bound by her past or to forge a better future, even if it means renouncing her vows and accepting a new and terrible power. Meanwhile, when the real enemy makes their bid for power, Yeneris must find a way to remain true to her full self and save both her mission and her heart.

As dead gods rise and corruption creeps across the world, this sweeping standalone fantasy tale of forbidden sapphic love and dark betrayal will set your heart ablaze.

Real History for Fantasy Worlds
by Deva Fagan

Which can you imagine more clearly: Middle Earth or ancient Mesopotamia? Which feels more real?

I’m guessing a lot of us (including me!) answer Middle Earth. Because a lot of the time, real world history is a dry, distant land populated by a few important dates and a few powerful kings.

As a writer who looks to real world history for inspiration, I’m always on the lookout for books and resources that bring ancient history to life. Not just the big events, the wars and plagues and discoveries, but the everyday happenings, the mundane details, and most of all the people. In the case of my debut epic fantasy House of Dusk, I drew much of my inspiration from the ancient civilizations of the Mediterranean and Near East. Here are some of the books that bring those peoples and civilizations to life for me:

Cover of Weavers, Scribes, and Kings by Amanda H. Podany Cover of The Amazons by Adrienne Mayor

Weavers, Scribes, and Kings: A New History of the Ancient Near East by Amanda H. Podany
What I love about this book is how it reminds the reader that history isn’t just kings and queens and earth shattering events. Through fragments of ancient cuneiform letters and records, we encounter a priestess complaining to her sister that “you never have a jar of good oil sent to me” in exchange for her offering up prayers on her family’s behalf. We meet a grouchy grandfather informing his estranged son that the grandchildren he had been raising have abruptly left his house and are traveling to reunite with their father (for reasons left tantalizingly unspecified). We learn what sort of equipment a Babylonian woman rented in order to set up an inn (three tables, ten chairs, a lampstand, a fermenting vat, a vessel stand, and more). Every person is the main character in their own story, even if we only witness that story in fragments. And that’s definitely something I want to apply to my own storytelling!

The Amazons: Lives and Legends of Warrior Women across the Ancient World by Adrienne Mayor
I’ve read several of Mayor’s books and found them absolutely fascinating (I also highly recommend The Poison King: The Life and Legend of Mithradates) but this one gets a special mention here for its focus on warrior women in the ancient world (not just the Mediterranean). As someone who writes books featuring a variety of “warrior women,” it was a thrill to read about the various real-world examples. As a bonus, the book also answers the burning question of “Who invented trousers?” (According to the Greeks, it was “barbarian” female warriors, making the wearing of trousers a transgressive and outlandish act, especially because it provided a degree of gender anonymity that Greek fashion did not allow).

Cover of If Not, Winter by Sappho, translated by Anne Carson Cover of Pandora's Jar by Natalie Haynes

If Not, Winter: Fragments of Sappho by Sappho, Anne Carson (translator)
A modern translation of the lyric poetry of Sappho, a poet who lived on the Greek island of Lesbos around 630 B.C.E. Sadly her music itself is lost, and most of her lyrics exists in fragments only, or in citations by other writers which may not be accurate. It’s bittersweet to read a poem when all that remains of it is “their heart grew cold; they let their wings down.” And while no translation can be perfect, there’s something numinous about Anne Carson’s language here that transcends time and makes me feel as if I truly am hearing the whispers of the ancient poet herself, seeing glimpses of her vivid, passionate, radiant, shadowy world. I can only hope that my own prose captures some of that magic!

Pandora’s Jar: Women in the Greek Myths by Natalie Haynes
One of the elements of world-building that I love the very best is playing with layers of myth that accrue over time. How so many stories are palimpsests: old versions scraped away but never quite gone, with new versions layered on top. There are many instances of this detailed in Pandora’s Jar, but I was particularly entranced by the chapter on Medusa, in which Haynes proposes that the earliest legend of Medusa might have been invented by the Ancient Greeks in order to explain the still older tradition of gorgoneions: statuary heads that served as protective icons to ward away evil. Haynes then traces the continued evolution of Medusa’s story from villain to vengeful hero to guardian of women. This sort of ambiguity is a key plot element in House of Dusk, in which the protagonists must sift through a multitude of different stories and legends and histories to understand the “truth.”

The Ancients Podcast, hosted by Tristan Hughes
Last but not least, if you want a shorter, more bite-sized bit of history across a wide range of topics, this is the podcast for you! One of my favorite episodes was #163, Race & Identity in the Greek Novel, with guest Dr. Mai Musié, Public Engagement Manager at the Bodleian Libraries in Oxford. This delves into the tradition of the “Greek novel,” a literary form popular in the Roman Empire that could be described as historical romances, as they take place in a fictitious Ancient Greece and feature young lovers striving to unite in a perilous world. Because many of the novels take place outside of Greece itself, they explore which peoples are considered Greek and which people are “Other.” While I didn’t look to Rome as an inspiration for House of Dusk, I did want to be mindful of how race and cultural identity might intersect in the fictional world I was building, in which there was quite a lot of historical migration, trade, and travel.

Historical events can sometimes feel just as far away and imaginary as fantasy worlds, but all these books and resources truly bring the past to life, reminding me that people have always been essentially human, striving and thriving, loving and hating, losing and triumphing as they did their best to make sense of the world they live in.

 

Photo of Deva Fagan by Deva Fagan
Photo Credit: Deva Fagan
Deva Fagan writes fantasy and science fiction for all ages. When she’s not writing, she spends her time reading, doing geometry, playing video games, hiking, and drinking copious amounts of tea. She lives in Maine with her husband and their dog. You can find her online at DevaFagan.com.

The Leaning Pile of Books is a feature in which I highlight books I got over the last week that sound interesting—old or new, bought or received in the mail for review consideration. Since I hope you will find new books you’re interested in reading in these posts, I try to be as informative as possible. If I can find them, links to excerpts, author’s websites, and places where you can find more information on the book are included, along with series information and the publisher’s book description.

Disclosure: I am an affiliate of Bookshop.org, and I will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.

Over the last week, I couldn’t resist getting the latest book by one of my favorite authors and a Humble Bundle with a lot of books by a great author!

Cover of A Covenant of Ice by Karin Lowachee

A Covenant of Ice (The Crowns of Ishia #3) by Karin Lowachee

The final novella in this trilogy set in a secondary fantasy world with dragons was just released toward the end of July (paperback, ebook, audiobook).

I’m a huge fan of Karin Lowachee’s science fiction novels set in the Warchild universe, and I’ve also been enjoying her new series of novellas, so of course I had to get the last book! The Mountain Crown, the first book in this trilogy, was one of my favorite books of 2024: one that felt like going on a journey with the characters, and one that obviously had a lot of thought and care put into it.

For more on the series from the author herself, you can read Karin Lowachee’s essay from this year’s Women in SF&F Month, “Character and Worldbuilding in The Crowns of Ishia.” She shared about the web of ideas related to character, culture, dragons, and magic that went into this fantasy trilogy, including some inspirations like the philosophy of wu wei and North American frontier literature.

 

The exciting conclusion to the gunslinging dragonrider trilogy!

After years of separation, Havinger Lilley has finally reunited with his lover, Janan. He now hopes to heal from the experience that changed his life forever: being bonded to the soul of a king dragon and to the man Raka who died to save it. But this bond is consuming him, making his thoughts and feelings not his own.

Compelled by this to return to the frozen north that was once Raka’s home, Lilley and his companions Janan and Meka make the arduous journey toward a confrontation with the power-hungry Kattakans that could result in another devastating war.

In this final chapter of The Crowns of Ishia series, the survival of the Ba’Suon people, their dragons, and the land itself rests on the decisions of Lilley, Janan and Meka.

Cover of All Systems Red by Martha Wells

The Murderbot & More Humble Book Bundle by Martha Wells

This Humble Bundle collection supporting World Central Kitchen contains ebook editions of all seven novellas and novels in the Murderbot Diaries series, plus two related short stories:

It also includes five (technically, seven) additional ebooks by Martha Wells:

The last three on the above list are updated and revised editions of earlier works. Witch King is Martha Wells’s most recently published new novel, and she discussed it in her essay “Deconstructing Epics” for Women in SF&F Month 2024, writing that she thought she was “writing a story set in the aftermath of a multi-volume epic fantasy” and then realized “the past and the present storylines were intertwined and equally important, to tell a story about found family and betrayal and fighting to preserve the world you fought so hard for.”

I’ve been thinking about getting back to The Murderbot Diaries series after enjoying the first season of the TV series, and this was the perfect opportunity to do that. All of these can be obtained for at least $18 and part of the profits go toward an organization dedicated to addressing food insecurity.

The description for All Systems Red, the first book in the Murderbot Diaries, is below.

 

Winner of the Hugo, Nebula, and Locus Award for Best Novella
Winner of the Alex Award
A New York Times and USA Today Bestseller

Now an Apple Original series from Academy Award nominees Paul Weitz and Chris Weitz and starring Emmy Award winner Alexander Skarsgård.

A murderous android discovers itself in All Systems Red, a tense science fiction adventure by Martha Wells that interrogates the roots of consciousness through Artificial Intelligence.

“As a heartless killing machine, I was a complete failure.”

In a corporate-dominated spacefaring future, planetary missions must be approved and supplied by the Company. Exploratory teams are accompanied by Company-supplied security androids, for their own safety.

But in a society where contracts are awarded to the lowest bidder, safety isn’t a primary concern.

On a distant planet, a team of scientists are conducting surface tests, shadowed by their Company-supplied ‘droid—a self-aware SecUnit that has hacked its own governor module, and refers to itself (though never out loud) as “Murderbot.” Scornful of humans, all it really wants is to be left alone long enough to figure out who it is.

But when a neighboring mission goes dark, it’s up to the scientists and their Murderbot to get to the truth.

If you missed the second quarterly Sci-Fi/Fantasy Book Recommendations event with the Ashland Public Library last night, you can catch the video on Youtube here. This included discussion of the following books:

  • Lips Touch: Three Times by Laini Taylor; illustrated by Jim di Bartolo
  • The Reformatory by Tananarive Due
  • The Girl Who Fell Beneath the Sea by Axie Oh
  • Blood Over Bright Haven by M. L. Wang
  • The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow
  • Death of the Author by Nnedi Okorafor
  • Beggars in Spain by Nancy Kress

We also enthused a bit about My Soul to Keep, the first book in Tananarive Due’s African Immortals series.

These are quarterly half-hour long discussions taking place on Zoom on the third Thursday of the month, and the next book chat will be from 6:30 to 7:00 ET on November 20. I’ll mention it again closer to the date, but if you want to sign up early, you can register for November’s event here!

The Leaning Pile of Books is a feature in which I highlight books I got over the last week that sound interesting—old or new, bought or received in the mail for review consideration. Since I hope you will find new books you’re interested in reading in these posts, I try to be as informative as possible. If I can find them, links to excerpts, author’s websites, and places where you can find more information on the book are included, along with series information and the publisher’s book description.

Disclosure: I am an affiliate of Bookshop.org, and I will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.

It’s been a while since the last one of these since April’s schedule was full and all of the books I’ve gotten since then were covered in my anticipated books of 2025 post. But it’s back this week with a book coming out next year that I’m very excited about!

Cover of To Ride a Rising Storm by Moniquill Blackgoose

To Ride a Rising Storm (The Second Book of Nampeshiweisit) by Moniquill Blackgoose

The sequel to To Shape a Dragon’s Breath will be released on January 27, 2026 (paperback, ebook, audiobook).

To Shape a Dragon’s Breath, which is set in an alternate version of our world that followed a different path in history and has dragons, won the Lodestar Award and the Andre Norton Nebula Award. Just last night, Moniquill Blackgoose became the latest recipient of the Astounding Award for Best New Writer.

I’m excited for To Ride a Rising Storm since the previous book was one of my favorite books of 2023. Although I usually prefer protagonists to have more internal conflict than Anequs has, I enjoyed reading about someone so secure in who she is and her willingness to call out harmful social rules was a delight.

Moniquill Blackgoose also wrote an article for Women in SF&F Month 2023 in which she discussed media representation (particularly indigenous North American representation) and creativity.

 

A young indigenous woman and her dragon fight for the independence of their homeland in this epic sequel to the bestselling and multi-award-winning To Shape a Dragon’s Breath, “a remarkable novel that is bound to be a staple of fantasy shelves for years to come” (BuzzFeed).

Anequs has not only survived her first year at Kuiper’s Academy but exceeded her professors’ admittedly low expectations—and passed all her courses with honors. Now she and her dragon, Kasaqua, are headed home for the summer, along with Theod, the only other native student at the Academy.

But what should have been a relaxing break takes a darker turn. Thanks to Anequs’s notoriety, there is an Anglish presence on Masquapaug for the first time ever: a presence that Anequs hates. Anequs will always fight for what she believes in, however, and what she believes in is her people’s right to self-govern and live as they have for generations, without the restrictive yoke of Anglish rules and social customs. And fight she will—even if it means lighting a spark that may flare into civil war.

One week from today, I’ll be doing a second quarterly virtual book recommendation event with the Ashland Public Library in Massachusetts. I’ll be sharing some fantasy and science fiction book recommendations on Zoom on from 6:30 to 7:00 PM EDT on Thursday, August 21, and if you want to join us next week, you can register here.

If you missed the first one, you can watch it on Youtube here. The books highlighted were as follows:

August Virtual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Book Recs with Kristen of Fantasy Cafe Graphic